Stone Coated Steel Shingles Vs. Asphalt Shingles

You are in the market for a new roof, maybe you’ve had storm damage or your roof has come to the end of its lifespan. With so many new products on the market every year, what do you choose? There are so many options from standard asphalt shingles to Class 4 impact resistant asphalt shingles to panel steel to hidden fastener steel to stone coated steel shingles. 

So what is the best option for your roof?

The short answer: Stone Coated Steel Shingles have the longest lifespan and highest hail resistance of any product on the market. They do cost 2 – 2.5 times the amount of asphalt shingles upfront, but typically save homeowners money in the long run. If you plan on living in your current house for more than 10 years or you want to increase the resale value of your home, stone coated steel shingles are the way to go.

 

Pros and Cons of Stone Coated Steel Shingles vs. Asphalt Shingles: 

Stone Coated Steel Shingles:

 

Pros: 

  • Long Lasting: Lasts 50-60 years 
  • Beautiful finished product 
  • Won’t rust: Galvanized Steel 
  • Corrugated for added strength 
  • Helps prevent ice dams 
  • Adds an insulation barrier to the roof 
  • Long term savings 
  • Highest hail resistance of any roofing product on the market 
  • Highly resistant to wind damage 

Cons: 

  • Expensive up front 
  • Slightly louder than asphalt in rain storms 
  • Less color options 
  • Technical product with fewer certified installers 
  • Installation takes longer

 

Asphalt Shingles: 

Pros: 

  • Lower cost up front 
  • More color options 
  • Quick Installation 
  • More certified installers 

Cons: 

  • Prone to hail damage 
  • More prone to wind damage 
  • Shorter lifespan
  • Standard look 
  • Higher long term cost 

Overall the decision on stone coated steel shingles vs. asphalt shingles comes down to a few factors, including, budget, longevity, years living in current home, and curb appeal of your home. If you are wanting a designer roof that you’ll only have to do once. Stone coated steel shingles are the best option for you. 

After going through the Pros and Cons if you are leaning towards asphalt shingles, there are some great options on the market. We recommend GAF products and specifically the GAF Timberline HDZ asphalt shingles. These shingles have a 50 year warranty, unlimited wind speed warranty, and a 15 year stain guard warranty.

If you are thinking you are ready to install a roof that will last forever and want to go with a stone coated steel shingle. We recommend the Tilcor Stone Coated Steel shingle. Specifically the CF Shingle. Renner Roofing is a Certified Installer for Tilcor stone coated steel shingles. Tilcor has the most durable, hail resistant, and best looking stone coated steel shingle on the market. Our team has carefully chosen Tilcor CF shingle as our stone coated steel shingle of choice after reviewing and testing many other products. What sets Tilcor apart from other products is that it is corrugated, adding strength and durability. Due to its corrugation, Tilcor CF Shingle is one of the few products that can be walked on without causing damage.